Choosing Your First Mystery Case

Starting strong matters. Use this simple rubric to choose a case that fits your group—and guarantees a great night.

Picking the right case maximizes fun and minimizes confusion.

Group size and energy

For 6–10 players, pick premade cases with flexible roles. For larger groups, choose modular clue packs.

Difficulty vs. fun

Beginner‑friendly cases use clear contradictions and minimal cipher decoding. Avoid heavy logic gates for first events.

Theme resonance

Match the group’s vibe: academia, crime caper, cozy mystery, sci‑fi station.

Time box

Aim for 90–120 minutes with two breaks. Keep the reveal to five minutes.

---

Starter checklist

1. Pick a theme and stakes
2. Assign roles and send briefs
3. Plan 3 acts of clue drops
4. Set ambiance (lighting, music)
5. Prepare awards for the reveal

Pro tip: Try one of our Cold Cases designed for first‑time hosts.